Discussion 2

: MAIN STORY
: The Alembic Plot

A knock on Medart's door didn't surprise him. "Come in, Mike--I've

been waiting for you."



Odeon entered, tying the belt of his robe. "You've had some sort of

odd experience too, then?"



"Yeah. A mental visit from someone who calls himself Satan, or Shayan,

or Lucius. Want some coffee?"



"I'll make myself some tea, thanks." Odeon busied himself doing so,

thinking that it was clear both of them were in seriously unfamiliar

territory. "Did he tell you anything useful?"



"Yeah, sort of, though it seems I can't talk about all of it."



Odeon snorted a laugh. "That doesn't surprise me! So much of this is

keeping secrets from various people, I'd be astonished if you could

tell me everything. At least I can tell you that the permanent

Protector's shown up, so Joanie doesn't have that problem any longer."



"Whoever it was did tell me that was happening. What nobody's told

anyone in the Empire is what the Protector is."



Odeon frowned, staring at his cup. "That's because Joanie told us to

avoid talking about religion. But I don't think we're going to be able

to avoid it any longer. You know I'm Catholic, and the bio sketch I

read on you says you're Omnist--which I'm afraid doesn't mean much to

me."



"Not practicing, but yes. And your version of Catholicism is a

variant; I studied Traditional theology on the way out here. In that,

and in other Christian faiths outside the Systems, there's no mention

of a Protector. Instead, it's Christ's second coming that's supposed

to start God's kingdom."



Odeon's frown grew deeper. "No Protector? But the Bible says--"



"Your Bible," Medart corrected. "I'm a little surprised you didn't do

any religious study, even though Joan told you not to discuss it. If

you want, I'll have my ship make you a copy of the Traditional Catholic

version, along with an outline of their teachings; except for the

doctrine of the Protector, that seems to be the branch your Founders

belonged to."



"I'd . . . appreciate that," Odeon said slowly. "You're telling me

we've been lied to?"



"Not necessarily." Medart paused, studying the other. "Will you be

offended if I give you the Omnist position on different religions?"



"I'll try not to be."



"Good. The primary tenet is that all religions are true in part, none

in totality--Omnism included. While the Creator's both infallible and

unchanging, the creations aren't; we change, hopefully mostly for the

better, and He gives us different religions to reflect our changing

needs. I'd say that for some reason, your Founders were given a

revelation about the Protector. I can't say how faithfully they



recorded it, or if any interpretations were accurate, but another of

our primary beliefs is that the Creator plays fair with His creations.

He doesn't lie, though we may misunderstand or otherwise screw up what

He shows us." Medart grinned. "You told me yourself the real

Protector's shown up, which should ease your mind on that score. Do I

know @, by the way?"



Odeon managed a smile. "You brought him. Joanie had Keith given his

tattoo, then made a comment about being anxious for the permanent

Protector to take over. Keith offered to take that burden from her and

had that offer accepted--I'm not sure by Joanie. Then he sent me here

to visit you, telling me I had a lot to learn."



"Keith, huh? Mind telling me what you believe the Protector is, now

that we know who he is?"



"Until a couple of minutes ago, I was certain the Protector was the

Third Person of the Trinity. Now you tell me there's nothing known

about him outside the Systems, when God is universal. So . . . I don't

know. Did Lucius tell you anything about him?"



"That he and the Protector are both restricted to the Systems, at least

for a time, and that the Brotherhood's their problem. Of course, if

he's who he claims to be, that could be a lie."



"Damn." Odeon rubbed the back of his neck. "He told me months ago

that his reputation as Father of Lies comes from humans who don't want

to believe him, that the truth was more useful and painful. Since that

hurts, it probably is true."



"It makes you feel betrayed."



"Yeah." Odeon sighed. The Ranger wasn't mind-touching him, but he was

certain that wasn't necessary; he'd never been very good at hiding

strong feelings, and his current feeling of betrayal was as strong as

his anguish at Joanie's maiming had been. "What would he be, then?"



Medart shrugged. "All I can give you is a guess."



"I understand."



"Okay. Bear in mind that I don't share your faith and ours uses

different terminology, so I'll have to do some more explaining, and you

may find that sacrilegious. Especially since you're a priest."



"I'm properly warned; go ahead."



"We'll start with the basic point we agree fully on, then. There is

one Creator of all the universes, right?"



"I only know of one universe, but other than that, yes."



"There are more. You'll have to take my word for now, but I'll give

you proof later. Anyway, you believe the Creator is three beings in

one, a belief I don't share. We do agree, though, that there are

lesser supernatural beings. Right again?"



"The various kinds of angels and demons, yes."



"And the souls of those who've died?"



Odeon thought about that, then nodded slowly. "I suppose so, though I

don't usually think of them that way."



"Even the saints, who work miracles?"



"God works the miracles through them," Odeon corrected. "Okay, I can

go along with all of that."



"Good, because the next step is where you're going to get upset. Since

everything ultimately comes from the Creator, including the power to

work miracles, Omnists don't see any practical difference whether these

lesser beings intercede, as you believe, and the Creator works the

miracle directly, or He delegates the power and they work the actual

miracle independently. Since demons in almost all theologies can work

the negative equivalent of miracles, and I don't think it likely they'd

ask the Creator's permission, I tend to the latter view."



Odeon didn't like that, but looked at from a purely logical viewpoint,

he couldn't argue. It was for damnsure Shayan could do things on that

order. "Go on; I can handle it so far."



Medart smiled. "You're doing better than I expected. Maybe you won't

blow up on me at this stage after all."



"I've heard a couple of Imperials swearing 'by the Creator and all the

gods', so I can make a guess. I don't like it one little bit, but I'd

say what we agree on as the lesser supernatural beings are what they

mean by the last part of that phrase."



"Exactly right! The Omnist definition of a god is a being subordinate

to the Creator who is the proximate cause of a miracle. It's not a

judgement of good or bad; it's a simple term to distinguish those who

work miracles from those who don't. And if the Creator chooses, He can

grant a material being the powers and knowledge normally restricted to

those on the supernatural plane. From what you tell me, He loaned

Joanie those powers temporarily, and has just given them to

Keith--maybe permanently."



"Umm." Odeon mulled that over for almost a full minute. That was a

little better than the absolute betrayal he'd felt before, but not by

much. "We were promised the Final Coming of God, and His Kingdom--not

a human transformed into an embodied angel or saint."



Medart sighed. "Mike, I wish I could offer you what you really need,

but that's the best I can do. If it's any consolation, I know and

respect Sandemans very much; you couldn't get anyone better for a

Protector than one of their warriors. The only change I can see

necessary for him to function that way, besides enhancing his natural

attitudes and abilities, would be for him to be given a more open

outlook sexually."



"I think he's been given that; at least he undressed when we did, and

said he'd take my place conducting his service. But--part of the

protection is from sin. How can he do that when he doesn't even know

what our sins are?"



"How do you know he doesn't, now? Giving him that information would

hardly be beyond the Creator's power."



Odeon rubbed the back of his hand, studying the blue circled triangle

on each. "Do you know what these mean?" he asked abruptly.



"No. I'm curious, but elsewhere it's one of the symbols of the

Trinity, so I didn't think I should ask just yet."



"It is? Here it started out as the Brothers' symbol, and when you see

it burned into someone's hands, it's a mark of their particular hatred.

When it's normal skin with a blue glow, like mine, it's the Protector's

Seal--means the person with them has given up the ability to sin." He

studied them for several more seconds. "Considering what I think about

being tricked the way we have been, I'm a little surprised he hasn't

taken these away."



"You're thinking standard human, not Sandeman warrior. I'm sure he

thinks you're perfectly justified in feeling betrayed, since he's not

what you were promised. While he can and will carry out the functions,

since he accepted the position, and in Omnist terms has apparently

become a god, he certainly isn't the Creator." Medart paused,

wondering if this were the time to broach the subject of Odeon becoming

a Ranger, or at least claiming his Imperial citizenship and moving to

Terra. Before he could decide, Odeon solved that problem for him.



"Jim--can I ask you something?"



"Of course. I'll answer it as the private individual I am here, or as

a Ranger, whichever you prefer."



"What's the difference?"



"As a private individual, I can take your feelings into consideration,

and the answer doesn't have to be complete. As a Ranger, you get it

all, with no shading. And I'll warn you in advance: most people don't

ask us questions, because they don't have the first option and they

know they probably won't like our professional answers."



Odeon managed a grin. He didn't mean it all the way, but Jim's

response did deserve something. "At this point, I'm feeling like

nothing can go right, and I don't know what to do about it. I've got

to work something out, so you might as well give me the professional

version."



"Okay. In that case, I'm going to give you one more out. Lucius told

me something that makes me want--need, under our present

circumstances--to get you into the Empire and a job that'll regularly

get you into dangerously interesting situations."



"I'm Strike Force, Jim, even though I was taken off active duty four

months ago because I'm Joanie's heir. Danger's normal for us; it's

only by God's grace I survived my first year, much less made it to age

thirty-seven. And right now, I've got to admit I wouldn't exert a lot

of effort to avoid getting killed. What job are you talking about?"



"Let me get to it more gradually, okay?"



"Okay, if that's your professional opinion."



Medart chuckled. "It is--and that answer gives me a lot of hope.

Besides feeling betrayed, I'd bet that being relieved of active duty,

and now having Keith take over your work with Joan, have you feeling

useless as well. Am I right?"



Odeon nodded, reluctantly. "I've been trying to avoid thinking about

that, but . . . yes, you're right. With Keith the Protector now, he

probably won't be helping her the way I did--she probably won't need a

helper any more, if he gives her the gifts the Herald was promised--and

I didn't really like the work, but it was the only productive thing I

was doing. Betrayal, uselessness--and I'm damn close to losing all my

faith."



Which sounded like it was tearing him apart, Medart thought. A lot of

people, even a few Rangers, needed a religious faith to feel complete;

it wouldn't be a violation of the separation doctrine to try and help

him regain his. "Don't give up till you read the Traditional church's

Bible and teachings, Mike. They might be just what you need."



"I hope so." Odeon hesitated, then decided to go on; as a police

officer, he knew that having all the facts was essential to reaching a

good decision, and he wanted the best Medart could manage. "The night

I was Sealed to the Protector--Joanie then, of course--Jeshua appeared

to me in a vision. One of the things he told me was that I'd be tested

by pain and loss great enough I'd be seriously tempted to reject him.

I thought earlier that Shayan torturing me was that, but I was wrong.

This is, and I hate it. It's a horrible feeling."



"I can tell," Medart said sympathetically. "Hang on; let me have that

material brought down right away instead of waiting till morning." He

touched his throat, gave the necessary orders. "Okay, they'll be here

in half an hour or so. Unfortunately, we don't have any Traditional

Catholics aboard, or I'd have asked one to come down and talk to you."



"The Bible and outline should be enough, if it's going to work at all.

I have a funny feeling I'm going to be up all night reading and praying

. . . Would you mind if we get back to the main subject?"



"Sure. I can't do much else about your feeling of betrayal, but I'm

hoping to get rid of the useless feeling for you." Medart paused,

smiled. "Even if you decide against the job I want you to take, if

those feelings are strong enough that you feel you have to leave the

Systems, all you need to do is claim your Imperial citizenship, then

exercise your option to change your world of residence once at Imperial

expense--in this case, aboard my ship."



"They're strong enough," Odeon said, "but I've still got a Family I

love and responsibilities I can't just run away from. I'll claim

citizenship, yes--the other, not unless you can persuade me the Empire

has more of a claim on me than my Family and the Archduchy of High

Teton do."



"I think I can manage that. Welcome to the Empire, Mike--I think

you're the first Systems person to take that step officially. Now

what's this about being Joan's heir, and an Archduchy? I don't

remember anything about you being part of the nobility."



"What?" Odeon frowned, thinking back over the past three weeks. "You

know, I don't think the subject ever came up. Joanie's Archduchess of

High Teton, and she named me her heir, which makes me a Duke. Local

nobility only, of course."



"Of course," Medart agreed, pleased that Odeon was showing even that

tiny trace of humor. "Shall I start calling you 'Excellency'?"



"I don't feel much like an Excellency at the moment. Just stick with

Mike, please."



He'd better slow down, Medart told himself. Mike was good, but he

wasn't Ranger-level yet, and if Medart screwed up, he never would be.

"Sorry; I was just trying to lighten things up a bit. If you decide to

take the job, you won't be able to inherit. Is the succession set up?"



Odeon nodded. "If anything happens to me, Sis' baby would inherit,

with her acting for him until he's of age."



"Good. No extra arrangements to make if you accept, then. Okay, Mike,

let me talk you through working out what job I want you to take; you

don't have the background to accept it if I just come out and ask."



"I asked for your professional help; we do it your way. I think I'm

starting to see where you're going, though."



"I hope so; that'll make it easier for both of us. I know you've read

about recent Imperial history, so you're aware of our losses during the

Traiti war and the White Order rebellion."



"Uh-huh--specifically the four Rangers, if I'm reading you right."



"You are. I was incredibly fortunate to find Ranger Losinj during the

rebellion, but we're critically short even when we have the average of

ten, and right now we're down to seven."



"You want me to be number eight, I'd say. We both know I don't have

even the widely-known qualifications, and I can't believe you'd

consider for a second lowering the standards, so--" Odeon broke off.

"Who's supposed to make the changes? If it's Shayan, forget it!"



"He told me about it, but it's the Protector who'll make you

Ranger-level, if you agree to the changes. Including the mind-set we

have to have, but again, only if you agree."



"That's a tremendous offer, Jim, and I can't deny it'd be a useful and

satisfying job--but I can't give you an answer just yet. First I've

got to work out my spiritual problem, and decide whether or not I'd be

willing to leave my family even for something like that."



"I can't do anything for you about the first, but maybe I can ease your

concern about the latter a bit. The one who mind-visited me said he

gave Family Cortin some of the same information he gave me; did that

include anything about an upcoming invasion I'm not going to be allowed

to warn the Empire about?"



"He didn't mention that part, but yeah, a super-nasty one. Why?"



Medart chuckled. "You don't need me to answer that; you can do it for

yourself, but I'll give you a hint if you want."



Odeon thought for a moment, then shook his head. "Don't bother. It's

pretty clear that someone who can command fleets would have a lot more

effect against invaders than a Strike Force officer who's been ordered

off active duty. Which means I could do more for the people I love by

leaving them than I could by staying with them." He paused, then shook

his head. "And that hurts too--especially since one of the public

things is that Rangers don't have any close personal ties, so if I take

the job, I won't even love them any more. Will I?"



Medart hesitated, but he couldn't either lie or refuse to answer. "No,

you won't. That's an emotion I've never had, other than maybe for the

Empire as a whole. Liking and respect for individuals, yes--love, no."



"And I won't miss it. I think that may be the worst." Odeon sighed.

"But you hit me in my vulnerable spot, Jim, and I think you know it.

I've spent my entire adult life doing my damndest to protect and help

people; if I can get past my spiritual problem, I'm going to have to

accept the job."



"If it's any consolation, none of us asked for the job, or particularly

wanted it--my own plans were to go through the Academy, have a Naval

career, and then retire to Herbert's World with a cattle ranch. Every

one of us, Corina included, took it on out of a sense of obligation."



More

;